top of page
Search

Why should a client choose you if you're not the cheapest?

Writer: Andrew Twomey
Andrew Twomey
Nov 3
5 min read

Differentiation beyond price


Primark, M&S and Gucci all sell coats. Nobody confuses them.


Primark sells low prices. M&S sells dependable quality. Gucci sells craftsmanship and prestige. Each knows what it stands for, who it serves and what it can charge.

Wealth management has the same choice.


Price is visible. Value isn't.


Fees are easy to compare. Value is harder to see. So clients default to the number they can see.


Your job is to make the value visible.


Clients may be paying for expertise, convenience, responsiveness, trust or the reassurance that someone who knows them will be there when it matters. They may value an adviser who has looked after their family for years, or a specialist who can navigate a complex business sale or international tax position.


None of these fits neatly into a fee comparison. All of it can justify a premium.


But there's a catch: you can't charge for value you merely claim to provide. Clients need to experience it, understand it and believe it makes a difference.


Make the value tangible


Much of the value of financial advice is invisible. A client sees the fee deducted from their portfolio, but may not see the tax saved, the risk managed or the costly mistake avoided.


When markets fall, an adviser who helps a client maintain perspective and avoid a panic-driven decision may provide enormous value. During bereavement, divorce or a business sale, their contribution may extend well beyond investment returns.


Firms need to make this value visible. Explain what has been achieved, which risks have been addressed, what decisions have been improved and what work happens behind the scenes.


Don't sell what you can't prove


Investment performance is a dangerous differentiator. Markets move, competitors catch up and past returns don't guarantee future results. Promising superior performance is a game few can win consistently.


Clients deserve something more credible: a clear investment philosophy, disciplined execution, appropriate diversification and returns that reflect the risks taken.


For passive investing, differentiation is harder still. If two funds track the same index, cost and tracking accuracy matter enormously. Scale has an advantage.

If you're selling a commodity, you need to be very efficient or offer a convincing reason to pay more.


Different clients want different things


Some clients want a dedicated adviser, specialist expertise and a highly personalised service. Others want a low-cost portfolio, a good app and minimal human contact.


Neither is wrong. The mistake is trying to sell one to the other.


Ryanair is a useful example. Its proposition is built around low fares, with customers accepting that some conveniences and aspects of service will be limited or cost extra. Customers can choose it with their eyes open because the trade-off is clear.


Wealth managers should be equally honest. If your proposition is low-cost and largely automated, say so. If clients pay a premium for personal attention, specialist expertise and proactive advice, explain what that means in practice.


You don't need to be the best firm for everyone. You need to be the right firm for the clients you choose to serve.


The experience must match the promise


A firm can position itself as premium, talk about personal service and charge accordingly. But if clients experience slow responses, repeated requests for information or poor coordination between teams, the promise falls apart.


A slick app can be copied. A concierge service can be copied. Even a compelling fee structure can be matched.


A durable advantage is harder to replicate: specialist knowledge of a particular client segment, exceptional coordination across investments and tax, deep family relationships or the ability to navigate complex international affairs.


The strongest firms combine a distinctive proposition with consistent delivery. A premium proposition isn't defined by how much it costs to provide or how sophisticated it looks. It's defined by whether clients experience the quality and value they were promised.


Transparency builds trust


Clients may accept a relatively high fee if they understand what it covers, why it's appropriate and what they receive in return. They may resent a lower fee if charges are opaque or unexpected.


Be clear about the total cost: advice, platform, investment and transaction charges, alongside any other relevant expenses.


Be equally candid about what you don't do, where your service adds limited value and when a simpler or cheaper solution would be appropriate.


That honesty doesn't undermine the sale. It can strengthen trust.


Reputation travels


Clients ask friends and colleagues. They read reviews and news coverage. They search online.


Increasingly, they'll ask AI which adviser or private bank they should trust.


Your reputation is what people say about you when you're not in the room.

Increasingly, it is also what search engines and AI systems can find and report about you.


A strong brand gets you considered. A credible reputation helps you get chosen. The experience you deliver determines whether clients stay and recommend you.


AI will change what clients pay for


As AI makes financial analysis, portfolio comparisons and routine planning more accessible, clients may become less willing to pay a premium for activities that previously required considerable professional time.


The fact that a task takes an adviser an hour doesn't automatically make it valuable. Conversely, a brief conversation that prevents a major mistake may be extraordinarily valuable.


The differentiators are likely to become clearer: judgement when the answer is uncertain, accountability when decisions have serious consequences, coordination across complex financial affairs, behavioural guidance when emotions threaten good decisions, and trusted relationships that provide context and continuity.


Technology may make information cheaper and expertise more accessible. It doesn't eliminate the need for someone who understands the client, challenges their assumptions and helps them make the right decision.


The question is whether your proposition reflects where clients will continue to see value.


The squeeze is real


Fees are under pressure. Regulatory costs are rising. Margins are tightening.


Scale, technology and efficiency can help. But cutting service to protect margins can undermine the very proposition that justifies your fees.


The answer isn't to avoid difficult choices. It's to make them deliberately. Choose your clients, define your proposition, design your service model around it and price it properly.


The firm with the lowest price, likely has the least loyal clients.


So what now?


Decide what you stand for. Be Primark, M&S or Gucci, but know which. Make the trade-offs clear, deliver on your promise and charge a fair price.


The worst position is Gucci costs with Primark service — or Primark prices with Gucci costs. One loses clients; the other loses money.


You don't have to be the cheapest. You do have to give clients a compelling reason to pay more.


And if a client is prepared to leave you over 0.05%, ask yourself why. Perhaps they're exceptionally price-sensitive. Or perhaps you haven't made your value clear enough.


Differentiate clearly. Make your value visible. Deliver on your promise. Charge a fair price.


That's how you compete without being the cheapest.

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Contact Us

07879 715379

info@aptthinking.co.uk 

London & Oxford, United Kingdom

Thanks for submitting!

© 2026 APT Thinking Ltd. All rights reserved.

Company number 17495776

bottom of page