top of page
Search

Why is moving providers so difficult?

Writer: Andrew Twomey
Andrew Twomey
Nov 3
7 min read

Migrating clients and advisers between platforms


Switching your bank account is almost pleasant. You choose a new bank, sign and the switch is done within days. Your balance, direct debits and standing orders move across. Your old bank even redirects payments for months in case you’ve forgotten something.


Now try moving a pension.


Forms. Requests for information. Letters that cross in the post. Queries that bounce between the old provider, the new one and the adviser. Weeks pass, then months. Nobody can tell you where it’s got to.


Same customer, same money, same wish to move. Completely different experience.


Why one is easy and the other isn’t


Bank switching is easy because it was designed to be. The Current Account Switch Service gives everyone a common process, a seven-working-day switch and payment redirection. Everyone works to the same rules, and customers know what to expect.


Pension transfers have no equivalent. Each provider has its own systems, processes and requirements. Some still rely on paper. Some insist on a physical signature, not an electronic one.


Information doesn’t always flow between the firms involved.


Pensions aren’t all the same. Defined contribution pensions can vary in complexity. Some pensions carry protected tax-free cash or other special protections that could be lost on transfer. Others are already in drawdown, meaning some benefits have been taken and different rules apply.


Then there’s the investments themselves. Some can move across as they are, known as an in-specie transfer. Others have to be sold, moved as cash and reinvested. That can mean time out of the market, dealing costs, tax implications, and a gap before the client is fully invested again.


That complexity is real. But it doesn’t explain every delay.


ISAs tend to sit between Cash Accounts and Pensions in difficulty of transfer. Bonds are very difficult to transfer due to the tax implications. Clients with Bonds are reluctant to transfer their Pensions and ISAs, as they want one provider across all of their investments, this creates a barrier to exit.


The pensions dashboard helps, up to a point


The pensions dashboard should let people find and view all their pensions in one place. Providers and schemes in scope are required to connect by 31 October 2026, but the public launch of the MoneyHelper dashboard is currently expected in the 2027/28 financial year.


That matters. Many people don’t know what pensions they have or where they are. Finding them should become far easier.


But a list of pensions doesn’t move a pension. Behind each headline value sit the details that make a transfer work: the type of scheme, what has been taken, any guarantees or protections, charges and investment options.


Better visibility is a start. The information and processes behind it have to catch up.


When difficulty is deliberate


Sometimes friction isn’t an accident.


Making it difficult to move assets, makes it difficult and riskier for advisers to move platforms and providers. This distorts the market, reduces competition, and can lead to poor client outcomes.


Providers want to keep assets, because assets bring revenue. Making it hard to leave helps hold on to them. Sometimes that means unnecessary hurdles or repeated warnings that nudge clients to stay put.


Often though, it’s simply poor operations. A firm that has merged with another keeps two systems in two places. A transfer request lands in the wrong one and gets rejected. A form goes missing between departments. A query sits in a mailbox nobody checks. A provider requires wet signatures.


Nobody meant to block the client. Nobody helped either.


For the client, it makes no difference. They can’t tell a deliberate barrier from a shambles. They just know they asked to move and nothing happened.


Regulation rightfully has a role to play here. A client can self select to transfer, but if an adviser wishes to transfer the clients assets it must be done in their best interests. That is reasonable. But for an adviser to transfer network, that could involve advising on hundreds of transfers concurrently, each requiring compliance approval, and each requiring a client meeting. The cumulative hurdle of this is a major barrier to exit.


The regulator will need to consider how they can enable clients to follow their advisers efficiently, whilst still protecting their best interests.


It helps to separate three kinds of friction:

  • Protective friction guards against scams, confirms identity or gives clients time to understand what they might give up. This is essential.

  • Administrative friction comes from repeated forms, manual processes, poor hand-offs and being asked for the same thing twice. This should be challenged.

  • Retention friction puts obstacles in the way to stop clients leaving. This has no place in a fair customer journey.


The aim isn’t to remove every check. It’s to remove everything that doesn’t protect the client or improve the outcome.


What the regulator found


The FCA has looked at how long pension transfers take. Its August 2025 review covered 18 life insurers, representing around 80% of individual personal pensions held by life insurers.


More than three-quarters of firms completed transfer requests in an average of 20 days or less. Where no extra checks were needed, more than three-quarters finished within 10 days. Where extra checks were needed, half the firms took between 41 and 80 days on average.


The felt experience by advisers would suggest it is longer. But that is the process before the application to transfer has been submitted – which is far harder to measure.


The FCA doesn’t set one timescale for every transfer. It accepts that some need extra checks to protect customers. But firms must act within a reasonable time and avoid unnecessary delays.


So speed matters, but so does the reason for any delay. Firms need to know what is holding transfers up, and whether the wait is genuinely necessary.


Who owns the transfer?


A pension transfer can involve the old provider, the new provider, the adviser, administrators and an investment platform. Each may be waiting for someone else.


The client sees one transaction. The industry sees several organisations, each with its own process.


So who owns it from start to finish? Who chases? Who tells the client what’s happening?


A good firm provides a single point of contact and takes charge of coordinating the process, even where it can’t control every party.


The receiving firm has a part to play too. Incomplete applications, unclear instructions and slow replies all add delay. It isn’t enough for each organisation to track how fast it does its own bit. The client doesn’t know who is slow. They care how long it takes until their money is back at work.


The receiving firm can do a lot to help:

  • explain the stages and likely timescales at the outset

  • check paperwork before it goes in

  • give a named contact and quick answers

  • provide real progress updates

  • explain what happens to investments, withdrawals and income while the transfer is underway


That’s a chance to stand out. A firm that makes the process clear and keeps the client informed shows its quality before a penny has arrived.


What it costs


For the client, delays cost money. Depending on the circumstances, they can mean missed investment growth, extra charges, postponed withdrawals or late access to pension income when it’s needed. Where investments are sold and moved as cash, the client may sit out of the market for weeks.


Not every delay causes harm, and staying invested during a transfer isn’t always possible. But firms should know what a delay can cost the client, not treat it as routine admin.


It costs the firm too. Angry clients don’t stay quiet. They tell their friends. They post online. Some write to the money pages of the newspapers. Some complain to the Ombudsman, which brings cost, management time and reputational damage, whatever the outcome.


Then there’s the internal effort of chasing, escalating, reworking and apologising. A transfer that takes three times as long takes far more work.


Learn lessons


Clients who leave well often still think well of you. They may come back. They may recommend you. They might even reconsider.


That depends on what happens next. Respond quickly. Be helpful and professional. Ask why they’re going, and listen. If the reason is fixable, say so honestly. If it isn’t, make leaving as painless as possible.


Don’t just record the departure and move on. Capture the reason and feed it back into the business. If clients keep leaving over poor service, confusing charges or limited investment choice, you need to know.


A client who felt respected on the way out leaves a very different impression from one who felt trapped.


Easier transfers, but are they better?


There’s a twist. Better data sharing and digital processes are making it simpler for clients to move their own pensions without help. That’s good news. Less needless friction means fewer stuck transfers and less frustration.


But easier doesn’t mean better.


Many clients don’t know whether they should transfer at all. They may lose valuable guarantees or protections. They may pay higher charges. They may move into investments that don’t suit them. A smooth process can make a poor decision feel painless.


This is where good advice matters most. The question isn’t just “Can I move?” It’s “Should I?”


Making transfers straightforward while helping clients understand their options is real value.


A fair exit


Making it easy to join is good practice. Making it easier to leave is the right thing to do.


Firms that earn loyalty don’t need barriers. Clients stay because they want to, not because they can’t work out how to go.


Firms that are only retaining their assets and their advisers by creating barriers to exit, are playing a short term game. Long term, advisers will not be drawn to work with them, reputation spreads, and those that do leave will make a lot of noise in the process.


If you were a client or adviser of your own firm, how hard would it be to leave?


What would you say about it afterwards?

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Contact Us

07879 715379

info@aptthinking.co.uk 

London & Oxford, United Kingdom

Thanks for submitting!

© 2026 APT Thinking Ltd. All rights reserved.

Company number 17495776

bottom of page