How do you compete with ChatGPT?

AI and the future of financial advice
How do you compete with ChatGPT? You don’t.
If you compete with ChatGPT, you lose. The real question is how you work with it.
The fox problem
An adviser I know recently tried AI for the first time. He used it to record a client meeting, summarise the discussion and list the actions.
The summary revealed that most of the meeting had been spent discussing the relative merits of urban and rural foxes. There was, rather disconcertingly, very little about financial planning.
Funny? Yes. But the client left happy, there was a check in regarding how they were doing, the relationship was stronger, and the AI had no idea why that mattered.
Keep that in mind.
Maths is a lost cause. Judgement isn’t.
At pure maths, AI is hard to beat. Ask it for the tax implications of a UK bond and you have an answer in seconds. Change the term, contribution, return or inflation and the financial plan updates instantly. Traditional tools can’t keep up.
But advice isn’t just maths. It’s judgement.
AI sounds convincing, empathetic and reassuring. It can also be overly agreeable, miss context and answer the wrong question correctly.
A good adviser knows what a client really cares about, challenges their assumptions and steers them towards their long-term interests. Clients don’t always know what matters most to them. Sometimes helping them find out is the job.
And AI is already reshaping accounting, tax and other professions. Xero has started to market that you can connect Claude and save on needing an accountant. Advisers aren’t immune either.
Start with the client
Don’t ask what AI can do. Ask what your clients value.
Some want the human relationship: trust, reassurance, an experienced adviser in their corner. Others want accurate projections, effective tax planning and strong performance, and are happy for AI to deliver much of it.
The answer isn’t human or machine. It’s deciding where each adds most value. Automated guidance for simple needs. AI-supported advice for sophisticated planning at scale. Humans for complexity, uncertainty and decisions with real personal consequences.
Choose your position. Don’t drift into it.
The business model is the battleground
If every firm has similar tools, AI alone is no advantage. The winners will redesign around it.
Saving 30 minutes on meeting notes is an efficiency gain. Serving more clients, responding faster and personalising advice at sustainable cost is a different proposition entirely.
AI will pressure fees, raise expectations and make previously uneconomic clients worth serving. Bolt it onto old processes and you keep the costs of the old model and add the costs of the new.
The opportunity isn’t just cheaper advice. It’s better advice for more people.
Your second pair of eyes
Advising can be lonely. AI is a colleague who’s always available to challenge your thinking: testing assumptions, spotting inconsistencies, flagging what you’ve missed. Firms can use it for compliance and fraud detection, and with proper oversight it may spot vulnerable clients earlier and more consistently.
But plausible isn’t the same as correct. Confidentiality, data security, bias and regulation all matter. AI can support the work. Firms remain accountable for the advice.
You can’t stop it
Advisers will use AI whenever it’s easier or better, whatever the policy says. So will clients.
Some platforms are now offering an integrated ChatGPT solution to their advisers.
Clients are already pasting reports into ChatGPT and asking whether their adviser got it right. Soon they’ll have personal AI assistants that interpret advice and prepare questions before meetings.
If AI becomes the client’s trusted interpreter, what makes you indispensable?
Not access to information, or producing a plan. Your judgement, your breadth of expertise and your willingness to take responsibility for complex decisions.
The human advantage
As AI takes on technical work, competence becomes the starting point, not the differentiator. The best advisers will ask better questions, challenge constructively and recognise when a correct answer is wrong for the individual.
Firms will need to consider how they manage the current generation of talent and how they train the next. How will juniors gain judgement if they no longer build the models?
AI will change what skills the best advisers need. With such a change in technology - will many existing advisers be the equivalent of experienced horse and carriage drivers in a new world of trains?
Competitors can access the same AI. They can’t easily replicate what you know about a client’s history, family and the reasoning behind past decisions. A transcript captures what was said, not why it mattered. It cannot spot emotion or nuance. Firms that turn that knowledge into secure institutional memory will deliver genuinely personal advice.
Will future AI get to know the client better than their own adviser? Picking up on things that the adviser failed to spot. Will future AI become so powerful that it is hard to differentiate from a real human?
So what now?
Let AI do the maths, the checking and the admin. Spend your time on what it can’t reliably replicate: understanding people, questioning assumptions, building trust and exercising judgement when the answer isn’t obvious.
The future advantage isn’t simply being human. It’s being trusted to make the right call when getting it wrong matters.
And knowing when an hour spent discussing foxes is the best investment you’ll make all year.
.png)



Comments